Lagrange Journal Get the app

Journal

The hardest thing to buy

What is luxury now?

· 7 min read

Luxury has always meant one thing: whatever is hard to get. What is hard to get keeps changing.

When the scarce thing changes

In the 1860s, Emperor Napoleon III of France had laid out for his most honoured guests. Less important guests ate with gold. Aluminium was then harder to produce than gold was to find. Today we wrap rotis in it.

In May 1833, a ship called the Tuscany left Boston carrying 180 tons of ice cut from frozen ponds. Four months later it reached Calcutta with about 100 tons still frozen, and caused a sensation. Ice houses went up in Calcutta, Bombay and Madras to store the shipments. The one in Madras still stands on the Marina, now known as . Today ice comes out of a tray in the fridge.

In 18th-century Britain, pineapples were so costly that families who couldn’t buy one rented one for the evening, set it on the dinner table to be admired, and returned it the next day.

Closer to home, in the 1980s, families waited years for a telephone connection, and a call to another city had to be booked through the exchange and waited for. Today almost everyone carries a phone.

Pepper from the Malabar coast once drew traders across oceans. Purple cloth was once worn only by emperors. Tea was once kept in caddies with a lock and key.

All of these became ordinary. And as they did, something went the other way.

were once the grains of households that couldn’t afford rice. Today they sit on premium shelves in city supermarkets. , the slow-grown country chicken, now costs more than the broiler. A night sky full of stars was once simply what you saw from a village terrace. In 2022, Hanle in Ladakh was declared , with limits on outdoor lights, and people now travel there to see what their grandparents saw every night.

Silence, clean air, and food grown slowly used to be the background of ordinary life. Now they are sold back to us, in headphones, purifiers and organic labels.

Even attention has joined the list. In 2018, the New York Times reported that families in Silicon Valley were asking nannies to sign contracts promising not to use phones in front of their children. Some resorts now charge guests extra to keep their phones in the concierge’s safe.

Two kinds of luxury

None of this means things stop mattering.

For many families, the luxury that counts most is still something you can touch. A pucca house that stays dry in the monsoon. A cool room on a May afternoon. A two-wheeler that makes the daily trip possible. A child’s fees paid without a loan. These are real, and they count.

Beside them sits a second kind of luxury, one that has quietly grown scarce for nearly everyone, whatever they own.

The same scarcity, in different clothes

Ask different people what they wish they had more of, and the answers sound unrelated at first.

  • For a daily wage worker, it might be a day off that doesn’t cost a day’s food. Rest without a penalty.

  • For a delivery rider, choosing his own hours rather than the next order handed to him.

  • For a homemaker, one hour in the day that belongs only to her. And someone, once in a while, asking what she would like.

  • For an elderly parent, a visit where everyone is fully in the room. Being listened to, not just looked after.

  • For a child, long, empty afternoons. Boredom, mud, and an adult who looks up when they come running to show something.

  • For a worker in the Gulf, a call home where the line holds and everyone is there.

  • For a woman in a city, walking home at night without planning the route around fear.

  • For an office worker, a full night’s sleep and an evening when nothing needs answering.

  • For the very rich, privacy. Often the one thing their money struggles to protect.

Look again, and many of these answers share something. Most of them are not objects. They are time that is truly one’s own, or attention that is truly given.

Why it is so hard to buy

Time and attention are strange luxuries. Everyone gets the same twenty-four hours a day, and yet most of us rarely feel we own them.

Time gets spoken for by work, travel, queues, and the small requests that arrive through the day. Attention goes to whatever asks for it loudest, and much of what asks has been designed to. A whole day can pass without our once deciding what to look at next.

Some countries now protect a little of it by law. In August 2024, a law came into force in Australia giving millions of workers the right not to answer their employers after hours.

Money can buy the setting for calm: a quiet room, a phone safe at the front desk, a weekend in the hills. It finds it harder to buy the calm itself. That part seems to come from somewhere else.

In Mohityanche Vadgaon, a village of about 3,500 people in Maharashtra’s Sangli district, a siren sounds from the Bhairavnath temple at seven every evening. Televisions go off and phones go down. For ninety minutes people read, study and sit together, until a second siren at half past eight. began it in 2022, after noticing that people no longer sat outside after dark.

The siren takes no one’s phone. It simply tells everyone, together, that it is fine to stop. Calm, it turns out, is easier to keep when the people around you are keeping it too.

Already within reach

Look closely at what the wealthiest people spend on living well, and much of it is familiar. Long sleep. A daily walk. Food cooked fresh from what is in season. Morning sun. Unhurried meals with family. A few friends who are honest with them.

Many ordinary days already hold some of these. What is scarce is often not the thing itself, but the time and the permission to have it.

Keeping yourself

So, what is luxury now?

Still a dry roof, a cool room in May, and the fees paid on time. Those don’t stop mattering.

And beside them, something that has become rare for nearly everyone, whatever they earn: time you control, and attention you can keep for yourself. An hour without being pulled. Deciding what you look at, and for how long. Being, for a while, entirely in one place.

Once kept, it can also be given. To a parent who wants to talk. To a child who wants to show you something. To the few people who would notice if you were gone.

The hardest thing to buy today may not be anything you can own. It may be your own time and attention, kept whole, and given where you choose.